The Ice Water That Changed Everything
Forty years ago next week, seven astronauts died when the Space Shuttle Challenger broke apart 73 seconds after launch. The world watched in horror. And then they watched Richard Feynman do something nobody at NASA expected: he found the truth with a glass of ice water and a C-clamp.
Appointed to the Rogers Commission investigating the disaster, Feynman quickly grew frustrated with the bureaucratic theater. While officials shuffled papers and protected reputations, he went directly to engineers. They told him what management didn't want to hear: the O-rings that sealed the solid rocket boosters lost their resilience in cold weather. The launch had proceeded at 36°F—well below safe limits.
During a televised hearing, Feynman produced a sample O-ring, dunked it in ice water, and squeezed it with a clamp. When he released it, the rubber stayed compressed instead of springing back. "I believe that has some significance for our problem," he said dryly. The room understood immediately. The engineers had been right. Management had been warned. The astronauts had died for a schedule.
"For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled."
That line, from Feynman's appendix to the commission report, remains the most quoted sentence about engineering ethics ever written. As we approach the 40th anniversary of the disaster, it's worth asking: have we learned anything? The answer, looking at recent Boeing incidents and tech company "move fast and break things" culture, is uncomfortably uncertain.